James Hardie vs LP SmartSide in Moore, OK
Energy-Efficient James Hardie vs LP SmartSide for Moore, OK Properties
Compare James Hardie vs LP SmartSide siding in Moore, OK. Get expert installation, local pricing, and a free estimate from Moore Siding Pros. Call (405) 956-2724.
- Licensed & Insured
- Locally Owned & Operated
- Free Inspection & Estimate
Request Your
Free EstimateChoosing between James Hardie fiber cement siding and LP SmartSide engineered wood siding is one of the most important decisions Moore homeowners face when upgrading their exterior. Both products are premium siding options engineered for durability, but they perform differently under the specific weather extremes Moore, Oklahoma dishes out — including destructive tornado events, severe hail, intense summer heat, and dramatic freeze-thaw cycles.
At Moore Siding Pros, we specialize in helping Moore, OK residents evaluate both products side by side, then install the one that best fits their home’s architecture, budget, and long-term performance needs. From established neighborhoods near SW 19th Street to newer developments south of I-240, our team understands the local building stock, climate stressors, and contractor standards that matter in Moore. Call us at (405) 956-2724 to schedule a free comparison consultation today.
Understanding James Hardie vs LP SmartSide: What Moore Homeowners Should Know
James Hardie fiber cement siding and LP SmartSide engineered wood siding represent two of the most popular premium siding categories sold in the United States today. Both emerged as high-performance alternatives to traditional wood siding and lower-grade vinyl, but they are built from completely different materials and manufacturing processes.
What Is James Hardie Siding?
James Hardie siding is composed of approximately 90% Portland cement, sand, and cellulose fiber. Invented in Australia during the 1980s and introduced to the U.S. market in the 1990s, fiber cement became dominant across Oklahoma and the Southern Plains largely because of its non-combustible nature and resistance to moisture intrusion. The product is available in lap siding, shingle panels, vertical panels, and trim boards. James Hardie’s proprietary HardieZone system divides the United States into climate zones, and Moore, OK falls squarely in the HZ10 zone — meaning products specified for Moore are engineered for hot, humid summers and cold winters with significant storm exposure.
What Is LP SmartSide?
LP SmartSide is an engineered wood product manufactured by Louisiana-Pacific Corporation. It is made from wood strands treated with zinc borate, a resin binder, and a proprietary SmartGuard manufacturing process that bonds a weather-resistant overlay to the panel face. Introduced in the late 1990s following LP’s discontinuation of problematic inner-seal siding, SmartSide has grown rapidly in popularity across Oklahoma because it closely mimics natural wood grain while offering better dimensional stability and moisture resistance than traditional OSB or plywood sheathing products.
Why the Comparison Matters in Moore
Moore’s housing stock includes thousands of homes built between the 1960s and early 2000s, many of which still carry original siding damaged by decades of severe weather. After the catastrophic May 20, 2013 EF5 tornado and the significant May 3, 1999 tornado before it, large portions of Moore’s residential neighborhoods were rebuilt. Many homeowners who rebuilt chose siding based primarily on cost or contractor availability rather than a true material comparison. Today, those same homeowners are revisiting their choices as warranties expire and Oklahoma’s weather continues to test their exteriors. Understanding the differences between James Hardie and LP SmartSide empowers Moore residents to make a long-term investment rather than a short-term patch.
Both products are available through fiber cement siding installation and siding installation services offered by Moore Siding Pros.
Our team in action — siding professionals serving Moore
Why Comparing James Hardie vs LP SmartSide Is Critical in Moore, OK
Tornado and Hail Impact Exposure
Moore sits near the center of Tornado Alley and has endured some of the most violent tornadoes in recorded U.S. history. The May 3, 1999 F5 tornado produced winds exceeding 300 mph along its path through neighborhoods like Westmoore and Riverpark, while the May 20, 2013 EF5 event generated winds measured at approximately 210 mph and cut a 1.3-mile-wide path through central Moore, destroying over 1,200 homes in established neighborhoods around SW 4th Street and Telephone Road. In terms of hail, Moore records an average of 8 to 12 significant hail events per year, with stones frequently reaching 1 to 2 inches in diameter during spring storm season. James Hardie fiber cement scores significantly higher on impact resistance in third-party testing, resisting hailstones up to 1.75 inches, while LP SmartSide can experience surface denting and coating damage from repeated hail impacts over time.
Oklahoma’s Expansive Clay Soils and Foundation Movement
Moore is underlain by the Garber-Wellington formation, a clay-rich geological profile that causes significant soil expansion and contraction with moisture fluctuations. During drought years — like the extended drought conditions Moore experienced between 2011 and 2014 — soils can shrink by several inches laterally, causing foundation movement that results in wall racking. Siding installed on walls that shift even a fraction of an inch can develop gaps, buckle, or allow moisture infiltration at seams. LP SmartSide, being a wood-based product, has more natural flex and can better accommodate minor wall movement without cracking. James Hardie, being rigid cement-based, can experience hairline cracking at joints if installation gaps are not properly maintained per HardieZone HZ10 specifications, which call for a minimum 3/16-inch gap at all butt joints in this climate zone.
Heat, UV Intensity, and Paint Longevity
Moore averages 230 sunny days per year, with summer temperatures regularly exceeding 100°F. UV exposure causes paint degradation on both products, but at different rates. James Hardie’s ColorPlus Technology finish is applied in a factory-controlled environment and carries a 15-year fade and chip warranty specific to the HZ10 zone. LP SmartSide requires field painting and its primer coat alone is not designed for long-term UV exposure, meaning homeowners in Moore’s south-facing elevations — especially in neighborhoods like Westpark and Eagle Crest — often see LP SmartSide field paint failing within 7 to 10 years without proper maintenance repainting cycles.
Moisture and Storm-Driven Rain
Moore receives approximately 36 inches of rainfall annually, much of it delivered in intense, wind-driven storms. Horizontal rain driven by 60+ mph straight-line winds — a regular occurrence from April through June — can force water into siding joints at pressures far exceeding standard installation test conditions. James Hardie is non-absorptive at its core, while LP SmartSide’s engineered wood core, though treated with zinc borate, can absorb moisture at cut edges and unsealed penetration points if field cuts are not properly primed within the manufacturer’s required timeframe. Both products require meticulous installation to perform as warranted in Moore’s storm environment.
For homeowners already experiencing siding failures from either product, siding repair and siding inspection services are available to assess current conditions before committing to a full replacement.
Signs It’s Time to Evaluate or Replace Your Siding in Moore
Structural and Moisture Indicators
- Visible warping, buckling, or bowing on wall panels, particularly on south- and west-facing elevations most exposed to Moore’s afternoon sun and prevailing storm winds
- Soft spots or sponginess when pressing against siding boards, indicating moisture infiltration into the substrate or wall cavity
- Water stains or dark streaking patterns running vertically below windows or horizontal trim boards
- Interior drywall staining, mold odor, or elevated humidity readings near exterior walls
Surface Condition Indicators
- Cracking, chipping, or peeling paint that covers more than 10% of any wall face — particularly common on Moore homes with south-facing LP SmartSide that has not been repainted within the past 8 years
- Hail impact dimples, dents, or punctures — even minor surface damage can allow moisture infiltration over multiple storm seasons
- Visible gaps at butt joints wider than 3/8 inch, or caulk failure at trim intersections
Urgency Indicators
- Siding installed prior to 2000 on a Moore home that has not been inspected since the 2013 tornado rebuilding period
- LP inner-seal era siding (pre-1996) still present on an unremodeled home — this product is known to delaminate and swell catastrophically
- Insect boring holes or evidence of woodpecker activity on LP SmartSide panels
Installation Methods and Approaches for Moore, OK Homes
1. Full Tear-Off and Re-Sheath
The most comprehensive approach — old siding and deteriorated sheathing are completely removed, new structural sheathing is installed, a new WRB membrane is applied, and new siding goes directly over a fresh, inspected substrate. This method is recommended for Moore homes built before 1985 with original Celotex fiberboard sheathing, which is commonly found in older neighborhoods near SW 19th Street and Eastern Avenue. James Hardie requires this approach when original sheathing cannot meet minimum nailing surface requirements.
2. Tear-Off Over Sound Sheathing
Old siding is removed, existing sheathing is inspected and repaired as needed, new WRB is applied, and new siding is installed. This is the most common approach for post-1990 Moore homes with OSB or plywood sheathing and is appropriate for both James Hardie and LP SmartSide installations. Siding replacement using this method typically takes 3 to 5 days for an average Moore home.
3. Over-Clad (Siding Over Existing)
New siding is installed over existing sound vinyl or wood siding using furring strips or direct attachment. LP SmartSide is generally more adaptable to over-clad applications due to its lighter weight compared to James Hardie fiber cement. However, over-clad applications can create moisture trapping issues in Moore’s high-humidity summer months and are only recommended when the existing substrate is confirmed dry and sound by inspection.
4. Board and Batten Vertical Installation
Both James Hardie and LP SmartSide offer vertical panel and batten products suited for farmhouse and craftsman-style homes increasingly popular in newer Moore subdivisions. Board and batten siding installation requires modified flashing and Z-channel details at horizontal transitions — details our crew is specifically trained to execute per manufacturer specs in Oklahoma’s wind-driven rain environment.
Ready for James Hardie vs LP SmartSide? Get Your Free Estimate Today.
Moore Siding Pros serves Moore and the surrounding area — we’ll be on-site within 24 hours.
📞 Call (405) 956-2724James Hardie vs LP SmartSide Cost in Moore, OK
Cost is one of the most frequently asked questions when Moore homeowners compare these two premium siding products. Here is a realistic breakdown of what to expect in the Moore, Oklahoma market as of current pricing conditions.
James Hardie Siding — Moore, OK Cost Range
- Materials only: $1.80 to $2.50 per square foot for HardiePlank lap siding in standard profiles
- Installed cost (materials + labor): $9.00 to $14.00 per square foot, depending on home complexity, story count, and trim detail level
- Average full-home project (1,800 sq ft home, ~1,400 sq ft of siding surface): $12,600 to $19,600
- James Hardie ColorPlus pre-finished products add approximately $0.50 to $0.80 per square foot over unprimed boards but eliminate the need for immediate field painting
LP SmartSide — Moore, OK Cost Range
- Materials only: $1.20 to $1.80 per square foot for standard lap siding
- Installed cost: $7.50 to $11.00 per square foot
- Average full-home project (same 1,800 sq ft home): $10,500 to $15,400
- LP SmartSide requires field painting after installation, adding $1,500 to $3,500 to total project cost for a typical Moore home
Location-Specific Pricing Factors in Moore
Moore’s active permit requirement adds approximately $150 to $400 in permit fees per project. Homes in areas with documented storm damage may require additional sheathing replacement, adding $800 to $2,500 depending on scope. Post-storm demand pricing — particularly in the 30 to 60 days following major Oklahoma hail or tornado events — can temporarily increase labor costs by 10 to 20% due to regional contractor demand spikes. Scheduling installations in Moore’s slower fall window (September through November) can sometimes yield better pricing and faster scheduling. Contact Moore Siding Pros at (405) 956-2724 for a current, itemized estimate specific to your home.
Moore, OK Neighborhoods and Surrounding Communities We Serve
Moore’s Central and Established Neighborhoods
Neighborhoods near SW 4th Street, Telephone Road, and Eastern Avenue represent some of Moore’s oldest residential stock, with homes built primarily between 1955 and 1985. Many of these homes carry original fiberboard or early vinyl siding and are strong candidates for a full tear-off and James Hardie or LP SmartSide replacement.
Westmoore and South Moore Subdivisions
The Westmoore corridor and subdivisions south of SW 19th Street include a large number of homes rebuilt after the May 20, 2013 tornado. Homes in this area are commonly 10 to 12 years old — now approaching the age where original builder-grade siding choices are showing accelerated wear from Oklahoma’s UV and storm exposure.
Norman, Midwest City, and Del City
We also serve homeowners in Norman, Midwest City, Del City, Oklahoma City, Newcastle, Choctaw, Nicoma Park, Spencer, Slaughterville, The Village, Valley Brook, Smith Village, Hall Park, Midway Village, and surrounding communities. Contact us for siding installation anywhere in the greater Moore metro area.
Siding Maintenance Tips for Moore, OK Homeowners
Regardless of which product you choose, proper maintenance is essential to maximizing your siding investment in Moore’s demanding climate. Follow these locally relevant tips:
- Inspect siding every spring after storm season — specifically in April and May when Moore’s most severe hail and tornado threats occur. Look for impact dents, cracked caulk, and displaced boards along north and west elevations where wind-driven debris typically strikes.
- Repaint LP SmartSide on a 7 to 10-year cycle — do not wait for visible paint failure. Moore’s UV index and heat accelerate paint breakdown; staying ahead of it preserves your warranty coverage.
- Maintain 6-inch ground clearance — Moore’s clay soil swells significantly after heavy rain. Ensure mulch, soil, and landscaping never contact your siding, which accelerates rot in LP SmartSide and staining in James Hardie.
- Clean annually with low-pressure water and mild detergent — Oklahoma’s red clay dust accumulates on siding surfaces and holds moisture against panel faces.
- Caulk trim intersections every 5 to 7 years — Oklahoma’s freeze-thaw cycles break down caulk faster than in milder climates.
- Check sprinkler heads each spring — irrigation systems that spray directly onto siding are a leading cause of premature moisture failure in both James Hardie and LP SmartSide products in Moore-area subdivisions.
- Schedule a professional siding inspection after any hail event producing 1-inch or larger stones — this size threshold, commonly exceeded in Moore, is sufficient to damage surface coatings on both products.
Frequently Asked Questions: James Hardie vs LP SmartSide in Moore, OK
Which siding is better for Moore, OK — James Hardie or LP SmartSide?
Both are excellent premium products, but they perform best in different scenarios. James Hardie is generally considered superior for Moore’s hail impact frequency and its non-combustible composition (important given Oklahoma’s wildfire risk in the Moore-Newcastle corridor). LP SmartSide is lighter, less expensive, and easier to work with during installation, making it a strong value choice for homeowners on tighter budgets or with homes that have complex wall geometries. The right choice depends on your specific home, budget, and priorities — our free consultation helps you make that determination confidently.
How much does James Hardie siding cost in Moore, OK?
James Hardie siding in Moore typically costs between $9.00 and $14.00 per square foot installed, including materials, labor, permit fees, and standard trim replacement. For a typical 1,800 square foot Moore home with approximately 1,400 square feet of siding surface, expect a total project cost of $12,600 to $19,600. ColorPlus pre-finished products are at the higher end but eliminate field painting costs.
How much does LP SmartSide cost in Moore, OK?
LP SmartSide installed in Moore typically ranges from $7.50 to $11.00 per square foot. For the same average Moore home, total installed cost ranges from $10,500 to $15,400 before painting. Adding field painting costs of $1,500 to $3,500 brings the total closer to $12,000 to $18,900 — bringing it within range of James Hardie’s ColorPlus products over a true apples-to-apples comparison.
How long does a full siding replacement take in Moore?
A typical full siding replacement on a single-story Moore home of 1,400 to 1,800 square feet takes 3 to 6 business days from start to final inspection. Two-story homes or homes with complex architectural details may require 7 to 10 business days. Permit processing through the City of Moore typically adds 3 to 7 business days before installation can begin.
Does James Hardie or LP SmartSide hold up better to Moore’s hailstorms?
James Hardie fiber cement consistently outperforms LP SmartSide in third-party impact resistance testing, with demonstrated resistance to hailstones up to 1.75 inches in diameter. Given that Moore records significant hail events annually — often including stones in the 1.0 to 1.75-inch range — James Hardie’s impact advantage is particularly relevant for local homeowners.
Do I need a permit to replace siding in Moore, OK?
Yes. The City of Moore requires a building permit for full siding replacement projects. Moore Siding Pros manages the permit application and inspection scheduling on your behalf as part of our standard installation service. Permit fees typically range from $150 to $400 depending on project scope.
Can I install new siding over my existing siding in Moore?
In some cases, yes — but it is not always recommended. Over-cladding is only advisable when the existing siding is in sound structural condition, dry, and free of mold or rot. In Moore, where storm damage and moisture infiltration are common, we typically recommend a full tear-off to inspect and address any sheathing or moisture barrier issues before installing a premium product like James Hardie or LP SmartSide.
Does LP SmartSide require painting after installation in Moore?
Yes. LP SmartSide ships with a primed surface that must be painted within 180 days of installation per manufacturer warranty requirements. Field painting cost is an important factor when comparing LP SmartSide’s initial purchase price to James Hardie’s ColorPlus pre-finished option, which ships ready-to-install and carries a 15-year finish warranty for Moore’s HZ10 climate zone.
Get a Free James Hardie vs LP SmartSide Estimate in Moore, OK
Ready to make the right siding choice for your Moore home? Moore Siding Pros offers free, no-pressure on-site consultations where we walk you through both products side by side, assess your current siding condition, and give you a detailed written estimate for your specific home and budget.
We serve Moore, Norman, Midwest City, Del City, Oklahoma City, Newcastle, Choctaw, Nicoma Park, Spencer, and all surrounding communities in the greater Oklahoma City metro area. Do not wait until your next hail season to address aging or damaged siding. Call us today at (405) 956-2724 or contact us online to schedule your free consultation. Moore Siding Pros — the local siding experts Moore homeowners trust.